The short answer
Work the ladder in order: wash first, because professional cleaning restores more oxidized aluminum than owners believe, for a few hundred dollars. Paint second, when color is chalked past washing but panels are sound, at a fraction of replacement cost. Replace only for widespread dents, failed panels, or when you simply want new, not because the siding looks dirty.
Three Answers at Three Price Levels
Postwar neighborhoods across Warren are wrapped in original aluminum — siding that has outlasted its original warranty and, with maintenance, can last for decades more. When it looks tired, three industries offer three answers: a washing company says clean it, a painter says coat it, a siding company says tear it off. All three are right sometimes. The order you should try them in is fixed: cheapest, reversible option first.
Branch One: Wash (Most Houses Stop Here)
Aluminum reads "worn out" for reasons that are mostly removable — decades of grime, organic film on the shade side, and light surface oxidation dulling the factory finish. A professional wash with aluminum-appropriate chemistry and low pressure takes all three off, and the panel color that emerges routinely surprises owners who'd been pricing replacement. Starting at $349, this branch costs a small fraction of re-siding and answers the question definitively: what's left after a proper wash is what the siding is. One check first: postwar houses also wore asbestos-cement shingles, which are easy to mistake for other siding and need different handling, covered in can you power wash asbestos siding.
Branch Two: Paint (When Color Is Truly Gone)
If washed panels emerge sound but chalky-white and colorless, the oxidation has eaten through the finish rather than sitting on it, and aluminum in that state takes paint exceptionally well. A washed, primed, professionally coated aluminum house typically holds its new color for 5 to 10 years before the next repaint, per This Old House and Fixr, at a fraction of replacement cost. The non-negotiable is the prep wash: paint over chalk and the new coat peels on schedule. On a house built before 1978, test the old paint for lead before any scraping or sanding. Our pre-paint guide covers the timing.
Branch Three: Replace (Real Reasons Only)
Legitimate triggers: widespread hail dents, panels torn or missing where matching stock no longer exists, chronic water intrusion behind the siding, or an owner who wants modern profiles and insulation and can fund the five-figure project. "It looks dingy" is not on the list; dingy is branch one. For scale, Fixr's national figures put repainting aluminum siding at about $4,000 to $6,300 and new aluminum siding at $5,400 to $20,000 for a 2,000-square-foot house. Those are general market numbers, not our prices. The most avoidable expense on this list is a replacement ordered for siding that a wash would have revived.
The chalk test: wipe a palm across a panel. Light white residue = normal aging that washes; heavy chalk that coats the hand after a fresh wash = finish gone, think paint. Either way the metal itself is fine: aluminum doesn't rot or feed insects, though it dents easily. It just gets dirty and eventually colorless.
The Bottom Line
Wash first. It's diagnostic and cosmetic at once. Paint when washing proves the color is spent. Replace when something is broken. Working the ladder in order often turns a replacement assumption into a house wash that starts at $349.
Sources
Want This Handled Properly?
Macomb Power Washing Solutions holds a 4.9-star rating across 179+ Google reviews, and free estimates go out within 24 hours. We carry $2M general liability plus workers' compensation.